EU seeks approval for Mercosur trade pact amid strong opposition

Post by : Monika

Photo: Reuters

For many years, the European Union (EU) has been working on a trade deal with a group of South American countries called Mercosur. This group includes Argentina, Brazil, Paraguay, and Uruguay.

Talks for this deal began almost 25 years ago, and after many ups and downs, the agreement was finally reached last December. Now, the EU is preparing to ask its member states and lawmakers to approve it.

This deal is one of the biggest trade agreements ever made by the EU. If approved, it would create a huge market of more than 700 million people and would cut tariffs, which are taxes charged on imported goods. Lower tariffs mean that goods like cars, machinery, wine, cheese, and farm products could be traded more easily and at lower prices between Europe and South America.

Supporters of the deal believe it would give both sides major benefits. For the EU, it would open up new markets for European companies and reduce dependence on other major economies like China and the United States. For South America, it would allow their goods—especially farm products like beef, poultry, and sugar—to reach Europe more easily.

Why Some Countries Support the Deal

Countries like Germany and Spain are strong supporters of the Mercosur deal. Germany sees it as a chance to sell more cars, trucks, and industrial machinery to South America. Spanish businesses hope to benefit in areas such as wine, olive oil, and construction equipment.

The deal would also help the EU secure important raw materials needed for the future. For example, South America has large reserves of lithium, a metal that is essential for making batteries used in electric cars and renewable energy storage.

As Europe works to switch from fossil fuels to green energy, having access to lithium and other critical minerals is very important.

Another reason supporters push for the deal is to give the EU more independence. Right now, Europe buys a lot from China and the United States. By strengthening trade with South America, the EU hopes to spread its trade partnerships more evenly and avoid relying too heavily on any single country.

Why France and Farmers Are Against It

Despite these benefits, the deal faces strong resistance—especially from France. France is the largest beef producer in the EU, and French farmers worry that cheaper beef from South America would flood the market and lower prices for their own products.

Farmers argue that South American meat may not follow the same strict rules that Europe enforces. For example, the EU has tough standards for food safety, animal welfare, and environmental protection. Farmers fear that imports from countries like Brazil might not meet these standards, creating unfair competition.

It’s not only France that is worried. Farmers in countries like Poland and Ireland have also raised concerns. They believe the deal could hurt rural communities that depend on farming for survival.

Environmental groups are another major source of opposition. They warn that the Mercosur deal could encourage deforestation in the Amazon rainforest. If South American countries try to increase their beef and crop exports to Europe, they may clear more forest land for cattle ranching and farming. This would release more carbon into the atmosphere and go against the EU’s climate goals.

The EU’s Safety Measures: “Circuit Breakers”

To address these fears, the EU has suggested adding special safety measures called “circuit breakers.”

These are emergency tools that allow trade to be paused if something goes wrong. For example, if imports of beef, chicken, or sugar suddenly rise too much or if prices drop so sharply that European farmers are badly affected, the EU could step in and temporarily stop imports.

Supporters say these circuit breakers would protect farmers and give the EU time to respond if problems arise. However, critics believe the measures are not strong enough to fully protect local farmers.

The Approval Process

For the Mercosur deal to become real, it needs approval from both the European Parliament and EU member states. At least 15 out of the 27 EU countries must support it, and together these countries must represent at least 65% of the EU’s population.

This is not an easy target. With France strongly against it and some other countries unsure, supporters will need to work hard to gather enough votes. Even if the European Parliament gives its approval, strong protests from farmers and environmental groups could pressure governments to block the deal.

What Supporters Say

• Those in favor of the Mercosur deal say it could bring a wide range of benefits:
• New markets for EU exports – European companies could sell more goods in South America, boosting industries like automotive, machinery, and food.
• Cheaper imports for consumers – Lower tariffs mean people in Europe could buy products like coffee, beef, wine, and fruit at lower prices.
• Access to vital minerals – The deal ensures supplies of lithium and other raw materials needed for electric cars, batteries, and renewable energy.
• Stronger global role – By making deals with South America, the EU strengthens its position in global trade and reduces dependence on China or the U.S.
• Supporters also say that turning away from the deal would be a mistake. After 25 years of negotiations, rejecting it now could damage trust between Europe and South America.

What Opponents Say

• On the other hand, critics list serious risks:
• Threat to farmers – Cheaper imports could push European farmers out of business.
• Environmental damage – Higher exports from South America may lead to more deforestation and harm to the Amazon rainforest.
• Lower standards – Some fear that food safety and climate rules could be weakened.
• Unfair competition – Farmers in South America may not have to follow the same strict rules as those in Europe.
• Opponents argue that while trade is important, protecting local farmers, rural communities, and the environment should come first.

The Bigger Picture

This trade deal is more than just about goods and money—it is also about politics and global strategy. By joining hands with South America, the EU shows that it wants to play a stronger role in shaping world trade.

If the deal goes through, it could become the largest free-trade zone in the world, covering goods, services, and investments. It would also show that the EU is still able to negotiate big agreements at a time when trade wars and protectionist policies are becoming more common.

For South America, the deal is a chance to diversify its exports and depend less on China, which currently buys much of its raw materials and farm products. Working with Europe could give these countries more balance and stability.

What Happens Next?

The EU will soon present the deal for approval. Over the coming weeks and months, debates will continue in national parliaments and in the European Parliament. Protests from farmers are likely to continue as well, especially in France. Environmental groups are also expected to push hard against the agreement.

Whether the deal passes or fails will depend on how much the EU can convince skeptics that farmers and the environment will be protected. If enough countries vote in favor, the deal could take effect within the next year or two. But if opposition stays strong, the agreement might once again be delayed—or even collapse.

The Mercosur trade deal is one of the most ambitious projects the European Union has ever attempted. It promises new opportunities for trade, cheaper goods, and access to important resources. But it also raises tough questions about protecting farmers, safeguarding the environment, and keeping food standards high.

Supporters see it as a chance to make Europe stronger in global trade. Opponents see it as a risk to farmers and the planet. After nearly 25 years of talks, the final decision is now in the hands of EU lawmakers and member states. Whatever the outcome, the debate shows just how difficult it is to balance economic growth, social concerns, and environmental protection in today’s interconnected world.

European Union trade